본문으로 건너뛰기
← 뒤로

[Humanitarian aesthetic surgery].

Annales de chirurgie plastique et esthetique 2003 Vol.48(5) p. 288-94

Knipper P

📝 환자 설명용 한 줄

【연구 목적】 인도적 목적의 성형외과 임무(humanitarian mission) 수행 시, 재건적 동기보다 미용적 결과가 우선되어야 하는지에 대한 윤리적·실천적 딜레마를 탐구한다.

이 논문을 인용하기

BibTeX ↓ RIS ↓
APA Knipper P (2003). [Humanitarian aesthetic surgery].. Annales de chirurgie plastique et esthetique, 48(5), 288-94. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2003.08.014
MLA Knipper P. "[Humanitarian aesthetic surgery].." Annales de chirurgie plastique et esthetique, vol. 48, no. 5, 2003, pp. 288-94.
PMID 14599904

Abstract

Must a face be disfigured by a terrible tropical disease, in order to make us realise that the well being of our gesture is aesthetically acceptable? Must our reparative motivation remain the only trace of our skill and our humanity? During a plastic surgery mission, so-called humanitarian mission, can this surgery be aesthetic? Can aesthetic surgery be humanitarian? We learnt from aesthetic surgery on humanitarian missions, that aesthetic is only a technic to assist the reparation aspect. There is no need to justify aesthetic by reconstruction, because aesthetic belongs, in its entirety, to reparation. There is no need either to feel guilty, when our technical gesture is aesthetic, since what really motivates our intervention is not for us to decide. Is the reparation of the cleft lip of a little Asian girl, a reparation gesture or only an aesthetic approach? You may think that this will be a reparation gesture, because it will be more "popular" or because you will reconstruct the muscular belt. This child will most probably look for a more beautiful or aesthetic lip (in any case, she ignores the intricacies of facial growth principles). Therefore, it will be an aesthetic intervention. Never mind the motivation, since your technic will be the same, and you will try to do your very best and the most aesthetically you can. Only the very intention behind an intervention will decide whether it is an aesthetic or a plastic intervention, whereas your technical gesture will remain the same. All this illustrates that our definitions are of a minor importance, compared with the mere satisfaction of our little Asian girl, which, hopefully, will be a "beautiful" satisfaction. In fact, we have learnt not to do aesthetic surgery, but to give an aesthetic approach to our surgery, even during our humanitarian missions. The form aesthetic surgery will take is very subjective and only the final result will have the last say. Hopefully this surgical result will be aesthetically and humanly acceptable.

추출된 의학 개체 (NER)

유형영어 표현한국어 / 풀이UMLS CUI출처등장
해부 muscular scispacy 1
합병증 facial scispacy 1
질환 tropical disease C1336827
Tropical Disease
scispacy 1
질환 cleft lip C0008924
Cleft upper lip
scispacy 1
질환 disease scispacy 1

MeSH Terms

Altruism; Child; Ethics, Medical; Female; Humans; Motivation; Physician's Role; Plastic Surgery Procedures; Surgery, Plastic

같은 제1저자의 인용 많은 논문 (5)