Treatment outcome of surgical and non-surgical endodontic retreatment of teeth with apical periodontitis.

[AIMS] To evaluate and compare the treatment outcome of root filled teeth with apical periodontitis treated either non-surgically or by endodontic microsurgery, and to assess the influence of an intra-radicular post, clinical and demographic factors.

[METHODOLOGY] Clinical and radiological data from 1157 patients with apical periodontitis in previously root filled teeth treated by postgraduate students at the Department of Endodontics, University of Oslo, between September 2010 and January 2020 with recall data at least 11 months from completion were studied. Surgical cases were scored using the Rud/Molven criteria and grouped into success, uncertain or failure at control. Non-surgical cases were scored with the periapical index (PAI) and similarly grouped into success, uncertain or failure at control. Chi-square analyses were used for comparison of subgroups of teeth treated and logistic regression analyses for assessment of the influence of clinical variables.

[RESULTS] Non-surgical retreatment was performed on 351 teeth and 107 teeth were treated with endodontic microsurgery, with overall success rates of 65.5% and 77.6%, respectively. The difference was statistically significant. Teeth with an intra-radicular post treated non-surgically (n = 30) were successful in 73.3% of cases, whereas teeth with intra-radicular post treated with endodontic microsurgery (n = 30) had a lower, 66.7% success rate. The distribution of tooth groups (anterior, premolar and molar) differed significantly between surgical and non-surgical cases, with maxillary anterior and premolar teeth more often treated surgically. Non-surgical retreatment cases were significantly influenced by patients' age (older patients had poorer outcome) and pre-operative PAI score (negatively correlated with outcome). Surgical cases were not significantly influenced by the factors studied here.

[CONCLUSIONS] The tooth type differed significantly for teeth treated by surgical versus non-surgical methods. Microsurgical treatment with apicectomy and retrograde filling showed significantly better treatment results than non-surgical retreatment of teeth with apical periodontitis, whereas treatment outcome in teeth with posts after non-surgical treatment tended to be better than after surgical treatment. Outcome of non-surgical retreatment was negatively influenced by older age and higher pre-operative PAI score.