Quality and accessibility of online patient self-education resources for breast reconstruction.
Abstract
[BACKGROUND] With rising interest in breast reconstruction after mastectomy, patients are increasingly turning to online resources to supplement medical consultations. However, the quality and accessibility of these materials remain inconsistent. This study evaluates the readability, understandability, actionability, content coverage, and transparency of online breast reconstruction resources.
[METHODS] The top 20 Google search results were examined for five common breast reconstruction-related queries. Metrics assessed included SMOG readability level, PEMAT scores (understandability and actionability), content coverage, and a modified EQIP score for quality. Statistical analyses examined relationships among these variables and with factors like search rank, author type, and query.
[RESULTS] Mean content coverage was 49 %, with significant gaps in preoperative planning, treatment side effects, and fat grafting. Readability was poor (mean SMOG 12.3). Understandability was high (80 %), but actionability (37 %) and quality (modEQIP of 40 %) were low. Academic authors produced shorter and lower-quality resources. Higher-ranked resources were generally longer and correlated with better performance across most metrics. Specific queries like 'DIEP flap' yielded narrower, lower-quality resources.
[CONCLUSIONS] Online resources for breast reconstruction are highly variable and often fall short in readability, comprehensiveness, and transparency. Although understandability is generally acceptable, low actionability and inconsistent coverage hinder patient utility. Search engine rank modestly correlates with quality, suggesting some alignment between visibility and value. Improving these resources will require targeted efforts to simplify language, address topic gaps, and enhance actionable content-especially for specialized queries where quality remains lowest.
[METHODS] The top 20 Google search results were examined for five common breast reconstruction-related queries. Metrics assessed included SMOG readability level, PEMAT scores (understandability and actionability), content coverage, and a modified EQIP score for quality. Statistical analyses examined relationships among these variables and with factors like search rank, author type, and query.
[RESULTS] Mean content coverage was 49 %, with significant gaps in preoperative planning, treatment side effects, and fat grafting. Readability was poor (mean SMOG 12.3). Understandability was high (80 %), but actionability (37 %) and quality (modEQIP of 40 %) were low. Academic authors produced shorter and lower-quality resources. Higher-ranked resources were generally longer and correlated with better performance across most metrics. Specific queries like 'DIEP flap' yielded narrower, lower-quality resources.
[CONCLUSIONS] Online resources for breast reconstruction are highly variable and often fall short in readability, comprehensiveness, and transparency. Although understandability is generally acceptable, low actionability and inconsistent coverage hinder patient utility. Search engine rank modestly correlates with quality, suggesting some alignment between visibility and value. Improving these resources will require targeted efforts to simplify language, address topic gaps, and enhance actionable content-especially for specialized queries where quality remains lowest.
추출된 의학 개체 (NER)
| 유형 | 영어 표현 | 한국어 / 풀이 | UMLS CUI | 출처 | 등장 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 해부 | breast
|
유방 | dict | 5 | |
| 시술 | diep flap
|
피판재건술 | dict | 1 |
📑 인용 관계
이 논문이 참조한 문헌 25
외부 PMID 24건 (DB 미수집)
- PMID 11884321 ↗
- PMID 12554556 ↗
- PMID 14517107 ↗
- PMID 14713661 ↗
- PMID 17363939 ↗
- PMID 18242935 ↗
- PMID 20496023 ↗
- PMID 20556435 ↗
- PMID 22683246 ↗
- PMID 24973195 ↗
- PMID 28178606 ↗
- PMID 28182805 ↗
- PMID 29064917 ↗
- PMID 30120087 ↗
- PMID 30710175 ↗
- PMID 31386570 ↗
- PMID 32072581 ↗
- PMID 32187068 ↗
- PMID 33673875 ↗
- PMID 34179407 ↗
- PMID 36997924 ↗
- PMID 37752312 ↗
- PMID 38046643 ↗
- PMID 38639789 ↗
🔗 함께 등장하는 도메인
이 논문이 속한 카테고리와 같은 논문에서 자주 함께 다뤄지는 카테고리들
관련 논문
- The impact of three-dimensional simulation and virtual reality technologies on surgical decision-making and postoperative satisfaction in aesthetic surgery: a preliminary study.
- Cutaneous fistula of the breast: A complication of cosmetic autologous fat transfer.
- Epidermal inclusion cyst after breast reduction mammoplasty.
- From Palliation After Angiosarcoma Resection to Totally Autologous Aesthetic Breast Reconstruction Combining Kiss Latissimus Dorsi Flap and Contralateral Breast Sharing Internal Mammary Artery Perforator Flap: A Case Report.
- Case report of a rare soft tissue tuberculosis in a patient undergoing lipoabdominoplasty.