Comparison of Accuracy of Subjective Measurement of Tip-Supra Tip Difference During Rhinoplasty Between Plastic Surgeons.

[INTRODUCTION] This study compared the subjective measurement of difference between the nasal tip and supra tip (TSD) (using eyes) versus objective measurement of TSD (by a ruler) during rhinoplastic surgery to determine the accuracy of subjective measurements among surgeons with varying degrees of experience.

[MATERIALS AND METHODS] In this analytical observational study, 40 cosmetic rhinoplasty candidates were involved. Those with the history of rhinoplastic surgery were excluded from the study. At the end of the operation, the surgeon was asked to estimate the TSD subjectively. The researcher, without the intervention of the surgeon, remeasured TSD by a presterile ruler. The researcher recorded both objective and subjective TSD measurements and the experience of the surgeon in rhinoplasty in the checklist.

[RESULT] Of 40 cosmetic rhinoplasty candidates, 17 were operated by a surgeon with >10 years' experience (group 1), and 23 by a surgeon with <5 years' experience (group 2). The results indicated that 5 surgeries (29.4%) in group 1 and 6 surgeries (26.1%) in group 2, had 0-mm difference in subjective and objective measurement. The difference of <1 mm between subjective and objective measurement was achieved in 13 surgeries (76.5%) in group 1 and 13 surgeries (56.5%) in group 2 (P = 0.191).

[CONCLUSION] According to the results, it can be concluded that the surgeon's experience is effective in reducing the differences in measurements of TSD in both measurement modes.