Automatic surgical skill assessment using a task classification model in laparoscopic sigmoidectomy.
[BACKGROUND] In surgery, the dissection-exposure time ratio indicates surgery efficiency and relates to surgical proficiency in laparoscopic colorectal cancer surgery.
- p-value p < .01
APA
Obuchi K, Takenaka S, et al. (2025). Automatic surgical skill assessment using a task classification model in laparoscopic sigmoidectomy.. Surgical endoscopy, 39(10), 6423-6429. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00464-025-12036-1
MLA
Obuchi K, et al.. "Automatic surgical skill assessment using a task classification model in laparoscopic sigmoidectomy.." Surgical endoscopy, vol. 39, no. 10, 2025, pp. 6423-6429.
PMID
40779134
Abstract
[BACKGROUND] In surgery, the dissection-exposure time ratio indicates surgery efficiency and relates to surgical proficiency in laparoscopic colorectal cancer surgery. This study aimed to develop an artificial intelligence (AI) model that automatically recognizes dissection and exposure times to explore surgical skill assessment.
[METHODS] Video datasets were constructed using laparoscopic sigmoidectomy (Lap-S) videos submitted to the Endoscopic Surgical Skill Qualification System (ESSQS). Videos were classified according to surgical skill levels into those with ESSQS total scores + 2 SD (standard deviations) above or - 2 SD below the average range: " + 2SD" and "- 2SD" groups, respectively. The times taken for dissection (D time), exposure (E time), invalid time (not contributing to the surgical progress) (I time), and Outside (the camera is outside the body cavity) were defined and annotated on the still images. The D/E ratio and D-E transition (number of times D and E are switched) were calculated. A convolutional neural network-based image classification model was developed, and each parameter was compared.
[RESULTS] Overall, 57 patients were included: + 2SD group, 26; - 2SD group, 31. The test data in both groups encompassed 386,721 frames: 223,954, 108,801, 35,304, and 18,212 in the D, E, I, and Outside times, respectively. The f1 scores for the DEI classification model were 0.92, 0.82, and 0.74 for D, E, and I. In the AI model, D time average was 3328 (± 739 SD) and 4073 (± 1018 SD) frames, and E time average was 1678 (± 681 SD) and 2748 (± 1337 SD) frames in the + 2SD and - 2SD groups (both p < .01). The mean D-E transition was 204 (± 96 SD) in the + 2SD group -significantly lower than that of the - 2SD group: 405 (± 188 SD; p < .01).
[CONCLUSIONS] New AI model automatically classifies Lap-S videos according to surgical proficiency based on "DEI" parameters and may help improve surgical quality and education.
[METHODS] Video datasets were constructed using laparoscopic sigmoidectomy (Lap-S) videos submitted to the Endoscopic Surgical Skill Qualification System (ESSQS). Videos were classified according to surgical skill levels into those with ESSQS total scores + 2 SD (standard deviations) above or - 2 SD below the average range: " + 2SD" and "- 2SD" groups, respectively. The times taken for dissection (D time), exposure (E time), invalid time (not contributing to the surgical progress) (I time), and Outside (the camera is outside the body cavity) were defined and annotated on the still images. The D/E ratio and D-E transition (number of times D and E are switched) were calculated. A convolutional neural network-based image classification model was developed, and each parameter was compared.
[RESULTS] Overall, 57 patients were included: + 2SD group, 26; - 2SD group, 31. The test data in both groups encompassed 386,721 frames: 223,954, 108,801, 35,304, and 18,212 in the D, E, I, and Outside times, respectively. The f1 scores for the DEI classification model were 0.92, 0.82, and 0.74 for D, E, and I. In the AI model, D time average was 3328 (± 739 SD) and 4073 (± 1018 SD) frames, and E time average was 1678 (± 681 SD) and 2748 (± 1337 SD) frames in the + 2SD and - 2SD groups (both p < .01). The mean D-E transition was 204 (± 96 SD) in the + 2SD group -significantly lower than that of the - 2SD group: 405 (± 188 SD; p < .01).
[CONCLUSIONS] New AI model automatically classifies Lap-S videos according to surgical proficiency based on "DEI" parameters and may help improve surgical quality and education.
MeSH Terms
Humans; Laparoscopy; Clinical Competence; Video Recording; Female; Male; Colon, Sigmoid; Artificial Intelligence; Middle Aged; Neural Networks, Computer; Colectomy; Aged; Operative Time